(AP) – A federal appeals court has decided to revive a US sales ban on Apple’s premium watches while it referees a patent dispute revolving around a sensor, raising the specter that the company will pull the devices from stores for the second time in less than a month.
The ruling issued Wednesday by the US Court of Appeals in Washington comes three weeks after it blocked the ban.
That temporary stay enabled Apple to renew sales of the two internet-connected watch models, the Series 9 and Ultra 2, embroiled in an intellectual-property fight with medical technology company Masimo.
The US International Trade Commission in late October ruled a blood-oxygen sensor in the Apple Watch models infringed on Masimo’s patents, resulting in Apple briefly ceasing sales of the Series 9 and Ultra 2 in late December before getting the short-lived reprieve from the appeals court.
Apple is still trying to persuade the federal appeals court to overturn the ITC’s ruling, but Wednesday’s decision means the company is no longer insulated from the US sales ban.
The appeals process is expected to take at least a year, meaning Apple will be forced to stop selling its latest watch models in the US through 2024 or perhaps redesign the devices in a way that complies with the ITC’s ruling.
In a Monday court filing, Masimo disclosed Apple has won approval from the US Customs and Border Protection on revisions that would remove the blood-oxygen sensor from the watches.
Apple didn’t have any immediate comment about how it will react to the appeals court decision, which revives the US sales ban on the Series 9 and Ultra 2 watches at 2 p.m. Pacific Time Thursday.
The Cupertino, California, company also could negotiate a settlement with Masimo that would clear the way for it to continue selling the Apple Watch models with the blood-oxygen sensor.
But in its appeal Apple has scoffed at the notion that its watches are relying on Masimo’s patented technology, making a truce unlikely.
Having to pull its two top Apple Watches from the US would put a small dent in the company’s annual sales of USD383 billion.
Although the company doesn’t disclose the volume of Apple Watch sales, analyst estimate the product accounts for about USD18 billion in annual revenue.
The US sales ban on the Series 9 and Ultra 2 won’t prevent Apple from continuing to sell its less-expensive model, called the SE, that isn’t equipped with a blood-oxygen sensor.
But that technology, which Apple introduced into its watch lineup in 2020, has been a key part of the company’s effort to position the devices as life-saving tools to monitor users’ health.
In court filings urging the appeals court to continue blocking the sales ban, Apple argued that enforcing the ITC’s patent order would cause unnecessary harm to “a pioneering product made by a quintessentially American company that directly employs more than 90,000 employees” in the US.
Masimo argued that Apple won’t be significantly harmed by the US sales ban of the Apple Watch models, given most of the company’s revenue comes from the iPhone.
What’s more, Masimo sought to portray Apple as a corporate bully engaged in the brazen theft of intellectual property widely used in hospitals and other health professionals that treat about 200 million patients annually.
