ANN/THE JAPAN NEWS – On September 1, 1923, the Frank Lloyd Wright-designed in Tokyo’s Hibiya district opening was literally earth-shaking – it coincided with the 7.9 magnitude Great Kanto Earthquake.
Wright designed a special floating foundation as the hotel site was located on soft ground.
After apparently helping the building escape damage, the design was hailed in the United States (US) as a remarkable accomplishment by an American architect. The building made people realise that it was possible to combine great design and disaster countermeasures.
However, in the 1960s, a decision was made to demolish the building due to ageing, prompting uproar in Japan and overseas.
“I think everyone would be happy if the building was relocated,” then-prime minister Eisaku Sato said, triggering the preservation of part of the building, which was relocated to the Meiji Mura open-air museum in Inuyama, Aichi Prefecture.
Although some experts were skeptical of claims about the building’s seismic resistance, the design influenced the construction of many other buildings.
“The so-called Wright architectural style was born in Japan because the Imperial Hotel building survived the earthquake,” said Meiji Mura Museum Curator Yuko Nakano.
The Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923 drastically changed urban development in Japan, raising awareness of the importance of seismic resistance as the country was experiencing rapid economic growth.
This series will look at lessons that can be learned from the past as Tokyo enters a new era of development.
Tokyo’s Marunouchi district is a typical example of an area that changed after the Great Kanto Earthquake.
The original Marunouchi Building, which survived the earthquake with only minor damage, was completed seven months before the disaster. The number of business tenants in the building doubled in the 12 months after it, helping to turn Marunouchi into one of Japan’s largest business districts.
Mitsubishi Goshi Kaisha, the precursor of current owner Mitsubishi Estate Co, conducted relief operations from the building in the wake of the Great Kanto Earthquake. This year, which marks the 100th anniversary of the disaster, will see Mitsubishi Estate conducting disaster drills with the Metropolitan Police Department for the first time.
The drills, which will involve firefighters and officials from a medical association, will include scenarios such as rescue operations and managing personnel who are unable to get home.
SEISMIC REINFORCEMENTS
Why did the Marunouchi Building, which was one of the largest buildings in the district at that time, only suffer minor damage?
About one-and-a-half years before the 1923 earthquake, when 80 per cent of the structure was complete, the walls of the building collapsed after a moderate temblor, prompting the designers to instal wall bracing as part of large-scale seismic reinforcements.
According to Kazunori Nomura of Mitsubishi Jisho Design Inc, that “bitter experience” helped minimise the damage from the major earthquake.
The original Marunouchi Building featured the latest Western technologies, and Mitsubishi Estate continues to review the quake-resistance performance of its buildings.
The current Marunouchi Building, which was completed in 2002, features a “quake-resistant shaft” that makes the building 1.5 times stronger than normal skyscrapers. According to the company, the concept is based on the design of a five-storey pagoda.
Mitsubishi Estate has also established its own quake-resistance guidelines that are stricter than legal and regulatory standards.
Many buildings in the Marunouchi district are high-rise towers that sit atop base structures that are about 30 metres tall, mirroring the height of office buildings of the Taisho era (1912 to 1926) when buildings could not exceed that level under law.
STANDARDS ESTABLISHED
The Great Kanto Earthquake significantly changed people’s thoughts on construction. In 1924, Japan’s first seismic standards were established in the urban building law.
After the earthquake, concrete was used more widely because of the drastic improvements in seismic resistance. Nevertheless, an approach of replacing old buildings with new structures has remained.
The average lifespan of buildings in Japan is said to be about 50 years, which is considerably shorter than that of the US and Europe, where it is common for buildings to stand for more than 100 years.
Earthquakes are only part of the reason. Tokyo’s population exceeded one million in the mid-Edo period (1603 to 1867) and the city was one of the most populous cities in the world.
Fires were common during that period as the city had many wooden buildings in densely packed districts and there was a cycle of rebuilding properties when they burned down.
During the bubble economy period, land and buildings were objects of speculation. Many buildings were demolished and rebuilt within the “statutory durable years” of the property to increase profitability.
A senior official at a major real estate company said, “About 30 per cent of buildings in Japan were constructed between the post-war and bubble-economy period. During those years, people tended to prioritise modernity over historical value.”
However, there are signs of change amid growing awareness of the environmental impact linked to the construction industry.
Sumitomo Realty and Development Co has decided to renovate the Shinjuku Sumitomo Building, which was completed in 1974. Nicknamed the Sankaku (triangular) building, it was Japan’s first skyscraper to top 200 metres.
Sumitomo Realty and Development is aiming to keep tenants and maintain rent revenues while extending the lifespan of the building, with the work expected to take several years to complete.
Reinforcements will be installed to reduce shaking in an earthquake, a parking lot will be turned into an indoor event space and restaurants on higher floors will be moved to lower floors to attract more visitors. The company is aiming for the building to reach its 100th anniversary.
“We’d like to prove that it can endure for a long period of time if appropriate renovations are performed, even in skyscrapers,” a company official said. “It turns 50 years next year, which is the halfway point.”
Meanwhile, the Tokio Marine and Nichido Building in Chiyoda Ward, which was also constructed in 1974, is set to be demolished and replaced with a hybrid wood structure scheduled to be completed in fiscal 2028. A lot of Japanese timber will be used in the building’s construction as part of efforts to promote decarbonisation.
The number of buildings in Japan over 50 years old is expected to increase in the future. But it remains to be seen whether Tokyo will be able to shake its scrap-and-build approach to urban planning as the push toward decarbonisation expands around the world.
