NEW YORK (AP) — Michael Cohen said during his congressional testimony on Wednesday that Donald Trump grossly overstated his wealth before becoming the United States (US) President, including inflating his assets during a failed bid to buy the Buffalo Bills in 2014.
The claim raises questions about whether Trump could face even more legal trouble if, as Cohen said, he misrepresented his worth in applying for a loan to buy the NFL team.
Experts said a criminal case against Trump appears unlikely for several reasons. But Cohen’s latest assertions could affect the court of public opinion at a time when lawmakers are discussing the possibility of impeachment.
Trump was one of three known finalists in the bid to purchase the Bills in the summer of 2014 following the death of franchise founder and Hall of Fame owner Ralph Wilson. He lost out to the owners of the NHL’s Buffalo Sabres, Terry and Kim Pegula, who purchased the Bills for USD1.4 billion. The third group was led by rocker Jon Bon Jovi.
Cohen, once Trump’s lawyer and one of his closest advisers before he pleaded guilty to tax crimes, fraud, lying to Congress and campaign finance violations, testified for hours on Wednesday before the House Oversight Committee.
As part of the effort to buy the Bills, Cohen said, Trump gave financial statements to Deutsche Bank in hopes of getting a loan.
The documents, which Cohen provided to the committee, said Trump’s net worth was USD4.55 billion in 2012 and soared to USD8.66 billion in 2013 because of the addition of a line item for USD4 billion worth of “brand value”— essentially the value Trump placed on his name.
Cohen told lawmakers Trump inflated his wealth “when it served his purposes, such as trying to be listed among the wealthiest people in Forbes,” even as he deflated assets to reduce his real estate taxes.
He didn’t go into specifics as to how the financial statements provided to Deutsche Bank were inaccurate or offer evidence backing his assertion they were inflated.
Duncan Levin, a former federal prosecutor, said Cohen is accusing Trump of a crime similar to mortgage fraud, a common offence in which a home buyer lies about his assets to get a loan.
“What he is laying out is something that is not only criminal but the type of behaviour that authorities investigate and prosecute every day,” Levin said. “It’s a bread and butter offence.”
If what Cohen said is true, he added, the President could be charged under federal law for wire and mail fraud or under New York state law for what is called “causing a false filing”. Such cases usually involve instances where the borrower gets the loan, but that isn’t required for all prosecutions.
The Trump Organization did not immediately respond to an email or call on Wednesday.
A Deutsche Bank spokesman declined to comment and would not say whether the bank has been contacted by investigators.
The US Attorney’s Office in Manhattan declined to comment.
The statute of limitations— five years for most federal offences — could preclude a prosecution. Trump could theoretically face criminal bank fraud charges if prosecutors could prove Trump intended to deceive with financial statements and that the bank relied on those figures, said Law Professor at Columbia University John Coffee.
The Justice Department, however, has held since 1973 that prosecuting a sitting President is unconstitutional.
Banks are sceptical of estimates of personal wealth, and Trump was well known for inflating the value of his assets. Trump once admitted in a deposition that his net worth calculations depend partly on “my own feelings”.
Brand value is part of what accountants call “goodwill” and is difficult to value. Companies frequently adjust goodwill because their estimates are so flawed. In 2017, publicly traded companies in the US admitted they overestimated “goodwill” by USD35 billion, according to the advisory firm Duff & Phelps.
While Trump said he could get USD4 billion for his brand, Forbes pegged the value at just USD125 million two years later.
The financial statement provided to Deutsche Bank said Trump’s ‘Seven Springs’ mansion and estate north of New York City was worth USD291 million in 2012. His 2018 government ethics filing said it was worth between USD25 million and USD50 million.
Questions were raised about Trump’s seriousness and value as he campaigned to get the Bills, but Cohen, who served as Trump’s spokesman through the process, insisted Trump was intent on acquiring the franchise. He insisted at the time that his boss was worth USD9 billion, citing Forbes estimates.
“There’s nobody more serious than Donald Trump,” Cohen said then.
His effort to buy the team included, according to some people who were involved, the creation of a fan group called 12th Man Thunder that pushed to keep the team in Buffalo amid speculation that Bon Jovi planned to move the franchise to Canada. One of the group’s leaders later said that Trump was secretly behind the creation of the fan group.
Depending on how much Trump sought to borrow from Deutsche Bank, it’s not clear the league would have approved Trump as an owner.
NFL rules require owners to control 30 per cent of the team and have a debt limit of USD350 million.
Trump submitted a non-binding bid for USD1 billion. He also submitted a binding bid, though the value was never revealed.
Trump, following his failed bid, said on Twitter he “would have produced a winner” even though he “refused to pay a ridiculous price” for the franchise.
“The @nfl games are so boring now that actually, I’m glad I didn’t get the Bills,” Trump wrote. “Boring games, too many flags, too soft!”