AP – The Federal Trade Commission on Thursday sued to block Microsoft’s planned USD69 billion takeover of video game company Activision Blizzard, saying it could suppress competitors to Microsoft’s Xbox game console and its growing games subscription business.
The FTC’s challenge could be a test case for President Joe Biden’s mandate to scrutinise big tech mergers. The commission voted 3-1 to issue the complaint after a closed-door meeting, with the three Democratic commissioners voting in favor and the sole Republican voting against.
The complaint points to Microsoft’s previous game acquisitions, especially of well-known developer Bethesda Softworks and its parent company ZeniMax, as an example of where Microsoft is making some upcoming game titles exclusive to Xbox despite assuring European regulators it had no intention to do so.
“Microsoft has already shown that it can and will withhold content from its gaming rivals,” said a statement from director of the FTC’s Bureau of Competition Holly Vedova.
“Today we seek to stop Microsoft from gaining control over a leading independent game studio and using it to harm competition in multiple dynamic and fast-growing gaming markets.”
The FTC said it was filing the complaint through its administrative process rather than taking the case to a federal court. An administrative law judge it set to hear evidence but not until August 2023, according to the complaint.
Microsoft’s president, Brad Smith, signaled in a statement on Thursday that the company is likely to challenge the FTC’s action.
“While we believed in giving peace a chance, we have complete confidence in our case and welcome the opportunity to present our case in court,” Smith said.
The company had been ramping up its public defence of the deal in recent days as it awaited a decision. Smith said Microsoft has been committed to addressing competition concerns and brought proposed concessions to the FTC earlier this week.
“We continue to believe that this deal will expand competition and create more opportunities for gamers and game developers,” Smith said.
Microsoft announced the merger deal in January but has faced months of resistance from Sony, which makes the competing PlayStation console and has raised concerns with antitrust watchdogs around the world about losing access to popular Activision Blizzard game franchises such as the military shooter game Call of Duty.
Antitrust regulators under Biden “have staked out the view that for decades merger policy has been too weak and they’ve said, repeatedly, ‘We’re changing that,’” said William Kovacic, a former chair of the FTC.
That has put pressure on the FTC to fulfill its bold promises to “not allow dodgy deals and not accept weak settlements,” said Kovacic, who was a Republican commissioner appointed in 2006 by then-president George W Bush. But he said Microsoft has a good chance of winning its legal challenge.
“It’s evident that the company has been making a number of concessions,” he said.
“Microsoft would likely raise them in court and say the FTC is being incorrigibly stubborn about this.”
Microsoft announced its latest promise on Wednesday, saying it would make Call of Duty available on Nintendo devices for 10 years should its acquisition go through.
It has said it tried to offer the same commitment to Sony.
In an appeal to Biden administration priorities, Microsoft had also sought to characterise its deal as worker-friendly after announcing a “labour neutrality agreement” in June with the Communications Workers of America that would allow workers to unionise after the acquisition closes. The union’s president, Chris Shelton, wrote an opinion column in The Hill this week calling on the FTC to “seal the deal, not blow it up”.
The deal is also under close scrutiny in the European Union and the United Kingdom, where investigations aren’t due to be completed until next year.
FTC’s decision to send the complaint to its in-house judge instead of seeking an urgent federal court injunction to halt the merger could drag the case out for months and give more “confidence to authorities outside the US to take a swing at the deal on their own,” said Kovacic, who is now a professor at George Washington University Law School.
Activision Blizzard CEO Bobby Kotick said in a message to employees on Thursday that the FTC’s action “sounds alarming, so I want to reinforce my confidence that this deal will close”.
“The allegation that this deal is anti-competitive doesn’t align with the facts, and we believe we’ll win this challenge,” Kotick wrote.
Kotick said the deal will be good for players, employees, competition and the industry.
“We believe these arguments will win despite a regulatory environment focused on ideology and misconceptions about the tech industry,” he said.
Led by FTC Chair Lina Khan, a legal scholar who’s advocated for tougher antitrust enforcement, the commission is made up of three Democrats and one Republican after a second Republican stepped down earlier this year and left an open seat on the panel.
