Lindsey Bahr & Anne D’innocenzio
AP – As thousands of protesters take to the streets in response to police killings of black people in the United States (US), companies are wading into the national conversation but taking care to get their messaging right.
Netflix’s normally light-hearted Twitter account took on a more sombre tone last Saturday, “To be silent is to be complicit. Black lives matter. We have a platform, and we have a duty to our Black members, employees, creators and talent to speak up.” That got retweeted over 216,000 times and “liked” over a million times.
The streaming service is just one of many corporate brands that have turned to social media to voice concerns over racial injustice after the death of George Floyd, a handcuffed black man who pleaded for air as a white Minneapolis police officer pressed his knee against Floyd’s neck for several minutes.
At the same time, companies must consider whether it makes sense for them to weigh in, especially on an issue as sensitive as race.
“It’s brand activism,” said Professor of marketing at Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management Alexander Chernev. “It’s not surprising. But companies have to think very carefully before they take a stand on these issues.”
There are plenty of examples of brands speaking out forcefully on social media, particularly in industries where cultural awareness is crucial. WarnerMedia, which is owned by AT&T and includes brands like HBO and TBS, changed their handles to #BlackLivesMatter and all posted the same James Baldwin quote, “Neither love nor terror makes one blind: indifference makes one blind”.
Twitter changed its iconic profile image to black with the Black Lives Matter hashtag. Media giant ViacomCBS tweeted “Black Lives Matter. Black Culture Matters. Black Communities Matter,” and announced that its cable properties like MTV and Comedy Central will go dark for eight minutes and 46 seconds to honour Floyd.
Nike, which famously took on the racial injustice issue head-on with its ad campaign featuring former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick, revealed a new video ad on Friday that bore the words, “For once, don’t do it.” The ad, a twist on its “Do it” motto, urged viewers not to “pretend there’s not a problem in America”.
But some companies that offered up statements of support were called out on their own track records on race. L’Oreal, one of the world’s biggest cosmetics companies tweeted, “Speaking out is worth it,” and pledged a “commitment” to the NAACP. That drew swift criticism online from those who see the company’s business model and advertising as focussed on white consumers.
Likewise, Amazon’s tweet urging the end of “the inequitable and brutal treatment of black people” received backlash from followers, who questioned the company’s own commitment during the coronavirus pandemic in which employees have been complaining about unsafe working conditions.
Other companies have been kept their messages broad. For instance, The Walt Disney Co and its brands, like Marvel, Star Wars and Pixar, all posted the same statement on Twitter about standing for inclusion and with the black community. Starbucks, which took heat in 2018 when two black men in one of its Philadelphia stores were arrested for not ordering anything, simply said it will stand in solidarity with black partners, customers and communities, “We will not be bystanders”.
Brand experts said corporate America needs to go beyond statements and outline what they plan to do to combat racism.
“Expressing solidarity with the Black Lives Movement is the right message, but everyone is jumping in on that bandwagon,” said Co-founder and Managing Partner of Metaforce a marketing and product consultancy Allen Adamson. “Just saying you are standing with them is nice but probably isn’t going to be meaningful for them or for the brand. It can be seen as opportunistic.”
Founder and CEO of WSL Strategic Retail Wendy Liebmann agreed saying there is no reason to make a public statement unless the company actually has a concrete plan to help resolve the issue of racism. She praised Peloton’s Twitter pledge to donate USD500,000 to the NAACP legal defence fund as an example.
Jeans giant Levi Strauss & Co is also backing its statements with money, committing USD100,000 to its longstanding partner ACLU. YouTube pledged USD1 million to support efforts addressing social injustice. And semiconductor chip manufacturer Intel is pledging USD1 million to address social justice and racism.
Some of the most moving statements so far have come from corporate executives who are black.
Marvin Ellison, president and CEO of home improvement chain Lowe’s tweeted a statement about growing up in the Jim Crow South and the company’s zero tolerance for racism, discrimination and hate. Citigroup’s Chief Financial Officer Mark Mason repeated Floyd’s words “I can’t breathe” in an emotional corporate blog post.
And Chairman and CEO of Kate Spade, Coach and Stuart Weitzman parent Tapestry Inc Jide Zeitlin, who along with Ellison is one of only a handful of black CEOs of Fortune 500 companies, noted in a heartfelt LinkedIn post to his employees that some of Tapestry’s stores had been damaged during the protests but he said his focus quickly turned to the looters after determining his staff was safe.
“What was going through their minds as they acted? Has our society truly left them with little to lose and few other ways to force the rest of us to come to the negotiating table?” he wrote. “We can replace our windows and handbags, but we cannot bring back George Floyd, Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, Eric Garner, Trayvon Martin, Emmett Till, and too many others. Each of these black lives matter”.